A workers' comp settlement in California resolves the claim in one of two ways. Stipulations with Request for Award pay permanent disability over time and usually keep future medical treatment open. A Compromise and Release pays a lump sum and usually closes future medical care. Either one takes effect only after a workers' compensation judge at the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board approves it as adequate.
Written and reviewed by
Last reviewed
| Settlement forms | Stipulations with Request for Award, or Compromise and Release |
|---|---|
| Approval | A workers' compensation judge must approve every settlement (Labor Code § 5001) |
| Future medical care | Usually stays open under Stipulations; usually closes under a Compromise and Release |
| Reopening | Stipulated awards: petition for new and further disability within five years of injury (§ 5410) |
| Medicare | A Medicare Set-Aside may be needed if you are, or soon will be, a Medicare beneficiary |
| Attorney fee | Typically 15%, approved by the WCAB, paid from the award |
How do workers’ comp settlements work in California?
A workers’ comp settlement in California is a written agreement between you and the insurer that resolves some or all of your claim. It takes effect only when a workers’ compensation judge approves it. Labor Code § 5001 makes approval mandatory, so the judge reviews every settlement for adequacy.
There are two settlement forms. Stipulations with Request for Award set your benefits according to the medical evidence and leave future medical care open. A Compromise and Release pays a negotiated lump sum and usually closes the claim entirely.
Most cases settle once your condition is permanent and stationary, meaning it has stopped improving. By then, a physician has usually rated your lasting impairment. Settling before the medical picture is clear risks undervaluing the claim.
What is a Stipulations with Request for Award?
A Stipulations with Request for Award is a settlement in which both sides agree on the facts of the injury and the permanent disability rating. The judge then issues an award based on them. The insurer pays permanent disability in installments, and future medical treatment for the injury usually remains the insurer’s responsibility.
- Payments The insurer pays permanent disability on a regular schedule until it has paid the total. In some cases, though, the WCAB may commute part into a lump sum.
- Future medical care The insurer keeps paying for reasonable and necessary treatment of the accepted injury, subject to utilization review.
- Reopening If the injury worsens, you can petition for new and further disability within five years of the date of injury under Labor Code § 5410.
- Limits Stipulations fit cases where the main issues are already agreed. Disputed questions, such as whether the claim includes a particular body part, are harder to resolve this way.
What is a Compromise and Release?
A Compromise and Release (C&R) is a settlement in which the insurer pays a single negotiated lump sum. In exchange, the claim closes, usually including future medical care. It can resolve disputed issues that Stipulations cannot, because both sides compromise instead of agreeing on every fact. That includes parts of a denied workers’ comp claim.
After a Compromise and Release, you pay for future treatment of the injury yourself or through other coverage. That tradeoff is the heart of the decision. A lump sum gives you control and finality, while open medical care protects you if the injury needs surgery or long-term treatment later.
You may be a Medicare beneficiary, or reasonably expect to become one. If so, a Compromise and Release that closes future medical care may need a Medicare Set-Aside so that the settlement accounts for Medicare’s interests. That can change how the parties structure the settlement.
How do Stipulations and a Compromise and Release compare?
The main differences are how the insurer pays you, whether future medical care stays open, and whether you can reopen the case. Neither form is right for every injury.
| Stipulations with Request for Award | Compromise and Release | |
|---|---|---|
| How you are paid | Installments of permanent disability | One lump sum |
| Future medical care | Usually stays open for the injury | Usually closed |
| Reopening | Possible within five years of injury (§ 5410) | Generally not possible |
| Disputed issues | Harder to resolve | Can be compromised |
| Judge’s approval | Required | Required |
How is a workers’ comp settlement valued?
The parties value a workers’ comp settlement mainly by the permanent disability rating. Any unpaid temporary disability and the expected cost of future medical care also count. Each piece rests on medical reports, which is why the QME or AME report often decides the range.
- Impairment A physician measures whole person impairment using the AMA Guides, Fifth Edition. See the QME process.
- Rating The Permanent Disability Rating Schedule adjusts the impairment for your occupation and age, producing a percentage.
- Apportionment Under Labor Code §§ 4663 and 4664, the rating can drop for disability caused by factors other than the work injury.
- Other amounts Unpaid temporary disability, penalties for unreasonable delay, and, in a Compromise and Release, the projected cost of future care.
Either side can contest a rating. A different reading of the medical report, or a better-supported report, can change the percentage and with it the value of the case.
Which other benefits matter when you settle?
A settlement is not only about permanent disability and medical care. Several related benefits depend on the timing and the wording of the settlement, and they are easy to overlook.
- Supplemental job displacement benefit A voucher for retraining or skill enhancement. It is owed when you have permanent disability and your employer does not offer you regular, modified or alternative work.
- Return-to-Work Supplement Program A separate state payment, run by the Department of Industrial Relations, for eligible workers who received the displacement voucher.
- Retaliation claims A Labor Code § 132a claim for discrimination because you filed is separate from the injury claim. The settlement should say clearly whether it includes or excludes that claim.
- Your job A workers’ comp settlement does not by itself end your employment. Any agreement to resign is a separate matter, and you should understand it before you sign.
An attorney can check that the settlement documents say what you understand them to say, including what you release and what you preserve.
What happens when a judge reviews the settlement?
When the parties submit a workers’ comp settlement, a judge at the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board reviews the documents. The judge then decides whether the terms are adequate. At that stage, the judge can approve the settlement, ask questions, or set a hearing before deciding.
The judge looks at whether the amount fairly reflects the medical evidence and the risks of trial. Equally, the judge checks that you understand what you are giving up. For a Compromise and Release, that includes confirming you know future medical care is closing. The judge also approves the attorney’s fee as part of the same order.
Once the judge issues an order approving the settlement, the insurer pays according to its terms. An approved Compromise and Release is final in almost every case, so the time to ask questions is before you sign.
What comes out of a workers’ comp settlement?
Several amounts can come out of a settlement before you receive it. They include the approved attorney’s fee, liens, and any advances the insurer already paid. The judge reviews these along with the settlement itself.
- Attorney’s fee Approved by the judge and paid from the award, not billed to you separately.
- EDD liens If you received State Disability Insurance while the insurer disputed temporary disability, the EDD can claim reimbursement.
- Medical liens Providers who treated you during a dispute may claim payment through the case.
- Permanent disability advances The insurer credits payments it made before settlement against the total.
If a third party also caused the injury, a separate lawsuit can affect the settlement through the insurer’s reimbursement rights. See third-party claims.
What does it cost to have a lawyer handle the settlement?
With this firm, the attorney’s fee in a workers’ compensation case is typically around 15% of the award. The workers’ compensation judge approves it under Labor Code § 4906, in the same order that approves the settlement. It is paid from the award, with nothing up front. The fees and consultations page explains how the firm charges for each practice line. For the rest of the claim, see the workers’ compensation overview.
Your first consultation is free and takes about thirty minutes; bring any settlement documents you have received.